MLB The Show 26 Trophy Guide

Roadmap to Platinum
Key Trophies & Tips
General Tips for Earning Trophies

MLB The Show 26 has a range of trophies that cover different aspects of gameplay, from completing storylines to mastering specific in-game challenges. Whether you're aiming for the prestigious Platinum trophy or just looking to collect some easy achievements, this guide will walk you through the steps to earn each trophy efficiently.

Roadmap to Platinum

The platinum trophy in MLB The Show 26 is relatively straightforward, with most trophies being easy to unlock by exploring various game modes. While some can be earned through regular gameplay, others require more specific actions or adjustments to gameplay settings. Below is a step-by-step guide to help you navigate your path to earning that elusive Platinum trophy.

Step 1: Early Gameplay (Exhibition Mode)

Start by playing exhibition games to unlock situational trophies. These trophies involve completing specific actions, such as getting a hit on GOAT difficulty or striking out an opponent. To make these easier, you can adjust the gameplay sliders and lower the difficulty setting. This will give you an edge while you focus on earning the early trophies.

Step 2: Road to the Show (RTTS)

Road to the Show is one of the most rewarding modes in MLB The Show 26, offering both fun and easy trophies. Focus on career progression, including developing your player and reaching milestones. Completing mini-games and equipping gear will unlock several trophies along the way. You'll also earn trophies by reaching specific goals, such as making it to "Gold" status in various mini-game challenges.

Step 3: Negro League Storylines

This year, MLB The Show 26 introduces the Negro League Storylines. Completing these storylines is a great way to earn a trophy. The "NLB Historian '26" trophy, for instance, is unlocked after completing all four of the storylines. Take your time to enjoy these narratives while working toward this achievement.

Step 4: Diamond Dynasty & Franchise

Once you're comfortable with the game, head into Diamond Dynasty and Franchise mode. In Diamond Dynasty, the "Gone Questing" trophy requires you to complete a Diamond Quest Map run. In Franchise mode, you'll need to handle front-office tasks and complete the "Horses in the Pen" trophy, which involves moving a starting pitcher to the bullpen.

Step 5: Cleanup (Two Controllers & RNG)

The final step is to clean up any trophies that require specific, often random, actions. For example, some trophies like “Robbing a Homer” or “Swim Move” rely on random events happening during gameplay. You can use two controllers in local play to make these easier. This allows you to trigger certain actions like home run robberies or special base-running moves, which are otherwise difficult to achieve with just one player.

Key Trophies & Tips

Here's a list of some of the key trophies and how to unlock them efficiently:

Trophy Name	Requirement	Pro Tip
Goat Mode	Get a hit or strikeout on GOAT difficulty	Adjust sliders to max out human contact/power and minimize CPU pitching to make this easier.
Swim Move	Dodge a tag at a base using a swim move	Player-lock a fast runner in Exhibition mode. Hold R2 just before the tag arrives to perform the swim move.
Horses in the Pen	Move a Starting Pitcher to the bullpen	In Franchise mode, go to Manager > Pitching Rotation. Move SP1 to the pen and set the open spot to "Bullpen Game."
Gone Questing	Complete a Diamond Quest Map Run	This mode is in Diamond Dynasty. You must complete a full run of the Diamond Quest Map to unlock this trophy.
Rally Cap	Get 7 hits in an inning when trailing	Enter a game late while trailing. Adjust sliders to make hitting easier and rack up those hits.
Robbing a Homer	Rob a home run at the wall	Can be easily completed during specific moments in the Negro League Storylines or in custom Exhibition games with perfect timing.

General Tips for Earning Trophies

Sliders and Difficulty Adjustments: Most of the trophies in MLB The Show 26 can be made easier by adjusting the gameplay sliders and reducing the difficulty. This is particularly helpful when working on trophies that require specific in-game actions, like getting a hit on GOAT difficulty or completing difficult mini-games.
Two-Controller Setup: Some trophies rely on random events (like swimming moves or home run robberies). Using two controllers in local play can trigger these actions more easily, allowing you to control both players and set up the situations needed for these trophies.
Explore All Game Modes: Be sure to take your time exploring Road to the Show, Franchise, and Diamond Dynasty. Many trophies are tied to progression and completion within these modes, so focusing on them is key to earning a good number of trophies.
Complete Storylines and Programs: Completing storylines, especially the new Negro League Storylines, will unlock a few key trophies. Also, participating in Diamond Dynasty programs and completing quests will lead to several trophy unlocks.
Be Patient and Persistent: Some trophies require perfect timing or an element of luck. If you're finding certain trophies difficult to unlock, take a break and return to them later, or experiment with different game settings to increase your chances.

MLB The Show 26 offers a mix of challenging and straightforward trophies. By following this guide, adjusting gameplay settings, and focusing on key modes like Road to the Show, Diamond Dynasty, and Franchise, you'll be able to collect most trophies quickly and efficiently. While some trophies may require specific actions or lucky events, using two controllers and tweaking gameplay sliders will make your trophy hunting much easier. Stay patient, and you'll be on your way to unlocking that coveted Platinum trophy in no time!

Cart