To complete the MLB The Show 26 Egg Hunt Program, you must collect seven specific eggs and complete 10 "Mystery Missions" (riddles).

How to Find Every Egg
Each egg is tied to a specific activity or game mode:
- Orange Egg: Complete all four Program Moments.
- Blue Egg: Complete the entire Egg Hunt Conquest Map.
- Yellow Egg: Capture all Strongholds on the Egg Hunt Conquest Map.
- Pink Egg: Complete the Diamond Quest Map.
- Purple Egg: Complete the Diamond Quest Map.
- Red Egg (Bonus): Tally 3 stolen bases in any Multiplayer mode (Ranked, Events, or BR).
- Green Egg (Bonus): Tally 10 doubles in any Multiplayer mode.
Mystery Mission Solutions
These riddles reward you with program points and require specific players or actions:
| Mission Riddle | Solution / Requirement |
|---|---|
| Wait a Third... | Win a game with Gold Clay Holmes (Yankees Team Affinity). |
| I'm Blue | Win a game with Kerry Wood in any mode. |
| Conq Mysterymaxxing | Get 1 Extra-Base Hit (XBH) with Troy Tulowitzki in Conquest. |
| Whoops, Not Supposed to Be There | Pitch 1 inning with A.J. Puk in any mode. |
| KYLE TEST | Hit 1 Home Run (HR) with any "Kyle" (e.g., Schwarber) in Diamond Quest. |
| Customizable Mini Seasons Length | Earn 500 PXP with players wearing #7 or #28 in Mini Seasons. |
| Back | Get 1 XBH with Nolan Arenado. |
| Back-to-Back | Get 1 XBH with Nolan Gorman. |
| Back-to-Back-to-Back | Get 1 XBH with Juan Yepez. |
| Back-to-Back-to-Back-to-Back | Get 1 XBH with Dylan Carlson. |
