Cart

Cart Empty

Continue Shopping
Total $0.00
Checkout
Home / Blog

List of New Legends in MLB The Show 26

Written by:  U4N
Published: Apr 11, 2026
27

MLB The Show 26 continues to bring excitement with its ever-growing roster of legendary players, both fresh faces and returning icons. The latest edition introduces over 220 legends, adding depth to the game with new arrivals and some legendary comebacks. Among the biggest highlights are Albert Pujols, a first-ballot Hall of Famer, and Felix Hernández, a fan favorite known as "King Felix." Here's a rundown of the new legends making their mark in MLB The Show 26, along with some fan-favorite returning legends.

New Legends in MLB The Show 26

List of New Legends

These players are either making their first appearance in MLB The Show or returning after a break, bringing their skills and legacy to the game:

PlayerPositionTeamNotes
Albert Pujols1B/3BCardinalsOne of the greatest first basemen of all time.
Felix HernándezSPMarinersKnown as "King Felix," a dominant pitcher for years.
Dustin Pedroia2BRed SoxA gritty second baseman, known for his leadership.
Andruw JonesCFBravesA legendary center fielder, with Gold Glove accolades.
Roy CampanellaCDodgersA Hall of Fame catcher with power at the plate.
Phil RizzutoSSYankeesA smooth shortstop and key player for the Yankees.
Graig Nettles3BYankeesKnown for his stellar glove and power at third base.
Jeromy BurnitzRFBrewersA powerful right fielder with solid hitting stats.
Jeff ConineLFMarlinsA versatile outfielder, remembered for his bat and leadership.
Dave RobertsCFRed Sox/DodgersA speedy outfielder, best known for stealing second in the 2004 ALCS.
Fred LynnCFRed Sox/AngelsA well-rounded center fielder with power and speed.
Red Schoendienst2BCardinalsA versatile Hall of Famer who excelled at second base.

Negro Leagues Storylines (Season 4)

The Negro Leagues Storylines brings several historical figures to life in MLB The Show 26, adding depth and diversity to the roster. These legendary players are part of the game's ongoing effort to honor the history of baseball:

PlayerPositionNotes
John Henry "Pop" LloydSSA pioneer in the Negro Leagues, one of the best shortstops of his era.
Mamie "Peanut" JohnsonPThe first woman to pitch in a men's professional league.
George "Mule" Suttles1BOne of the best power hitters in Negro Leagues history.
Buy the show 26 stubs

Prominent Returning Legends

In addition to the newcomers, MLB The Show 26 continues to feature iconic legends from previous editions. These familiar faces remain beloved in the game:

PlayerPositionTeamNotes
Mickey MantleCFYankeesA switch-hitting legend and Hall of Famer.
Ken Griffey Jr.CFMarinersArguably the greatest center fielder ever.
Hank AaronRFBravesA true home run king and Hall of Famer.
Roberto ClementeRFPiratesA beloved legend known for his hitting and humanitarian work.
Randy JohnsonSPDiamondbacksThe "Big Unit," a dominant left-handed pitcher.
Manny RamirezLFRed SoxA prolific hitter with a World Series ring.
Troy TulowitzkiSSRockiesA gold glove shortstop with offensive power.

Notable Removed Legends

While MLB The Show 26 introduces exciting new faces, there are a few fan-favorite legends missing from the roster this year. These players, previously staples of the game, are not included in the latest version:

PlayerPositionTeamNotes
Frank Thomas1B/DHWhite SoxA power-hitting legend, missed by many.
Rickey HendersonLFAthleticsThe all-time leader in stolen bases.
Tim RainesLFExposKnown for his speed and on-base skills.
Todd Helton1BRockiesA consistent hitter and one of the best first basemen.
Jim PalmerSPOriolesA Hall of Fame pitcher and Orioles legend.

MLB The Show 26 is filled with both new legends and returning favorites, bringing some of the most iconic players in baseball history to your fingertips. Whether you're looking to relive the glory of Albert Pujols' legendary career or experience the return of Felix Hernández's dominance on the mound, this game offers something for everyone. The Negro Leagues Storylines also give players a chance to appreciate the rich, untold history of baseball, making MLB The Show 26 the most diverse and exciting edition yet.

PREVIOUS Next

About the Author: U4N

U4N is a leading online marketplace offering secure, fast transactions for in-game items, currencies, accounts and boosting services. Covering a wide range of popular games, U4N provides players with reliable services, including fast delivery and verified sellers, ensuring a smooth and safe gaming experience.

Related Articles