Cart

Cart Empty

Continue Shopping
Total $0.00
Checkout
Home / Blog / MLB The Show 26

List of Legends in MLB The Show 26

Written by:  U4N
Published: Mar 19, 2026
1257

MLB The Show 26 includes one of the largest legend rosters the series has seen. At launch, the game features over 220 legends, covering multiple eras of baseball history.

The roster combines new additions, returning stars, and a few notable absences. This guide breaks down each group clearly so you know what to expect.

New Legends in MLB The Show 26

Several well-known players are making their debut, or returning after being out of the series for years. These additions help refresh team-building options, especially in Diamond Dynasty.

Here are the confirmed new legends:

  • Albert Pujols (1B, Cardinals / Dodgers / Angels)
  • Felix Hernández (SP, Mariners)
  • Dustin Pedroia (2B, Red Sox)
  • Andruw Jones (CF, Braves)
  • Roy Campanella (C, Dodgers)
  • Adam Jones (CF, Orioles)
  • Troy Tulowitzki (SS, Rockies / Blue Jays)
  • Jeff Conine (LF / 1B, Marlins)
  • Fred Lynn (CF, Red Sox / Angels)
  • Dave Roberts (CF, Dodgers / Padres)
  • Graig Nettles (3B, Yankees / Padres)
  • Jeromy Burnitz (RF, Brewers / Mets)
  • Phil Rizzuto (SS, Yankees)
  • Red Schoendienst (2B, Cardinals)

These players add depth across multiple positions. Some, like Pujols and Hernández, are expected to be high-impact options. Others provide more specialized value depending on playstyle and roster needs.

If you want to try some of these new legends right away, building stubs steadily is still the safest approach. Playing programs, flipping cards, and completing collections can get you there over time. For players who prefer a more direct route, it may be worth looking at a reliable MLB 26 stubs deal from a known platform like U4N, as long as you stay within your comfort level and understand the risks involved.

MLB The Show 26 New Negro Leagues Legends

New Negro Leagues Legends

MLB The Show 26 continues expanding its Negro Leagues Storylines mode. This remains one of the more educational and unique parts of the game.

New additions include:

  • John Henry “Pop” Lloyd
  • Mamie “Peanut” Johnson
  • George “Mule” Suttles

These players are integrated through Storylines content, where you unlock them by completing historical moments. This approach focuses on context and history, not just gameplay stats.

Returning and Featured Legends

Many of the most popular legends return in MLB The Show 26. These players continue to be central to both offline modes and competitive play.

Key returning legends include:

  • Ken Griffey Jr.
  • Randy Johnson
  • Mickey Mantle
  • Hank Aaron
  • Roberto Clemente
  • Chipper Jones
  • Roy Halladay

These names are familiar to long-time players. They are often used as cornerstone cards due to their balanced attributes and strong in-game performance.

Removed or Missing Legends

Not every legend returns each year. In MLB The Show 26, several players from MLB The Show 25 are not included at launch.

Notable absences:

  • Prince Fielder
  • Joe Nathan
  • Jason Bay
  • Fernando Valenzuela
  • Eric Davis
  • Don Mattingly

In most cases, these changes are related to licensing agreements rather than gameplay decisions. It is also possible that some players could return later through updates or special programs.

PREVIOUS Next
About the Author

The U4N Editorial Team is made up of dedicated gamers and technical experts. We're not just a trusted marketplace for game assets—we're all about empowering players with top-tier, expert-driven content. Our team produces in-depth guides, strategies, and technical fixes for some of the biggest games out there, like MLB The Show 26, Aion 2, Forza Horizon 6, Arc Raiders, and Path of Exile.

Whether it's mastering market flipping in Diamond Dynasty or optimizing your endgame builds, all of our strategies are tested and proven by in-house experts. At U4N, we don't just follow the meta—we help you stay ahead of it.

Related Articles